A. PROJECT TITLE: THE MADISON
PROJECT OF SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY AND WEBSTER COLLEGE
B. PROJECT
DIRECTOR: Professor
Robert B. Davis, Mathematics Department, Smith Hall, Syracuse University,
Syracuse, New York 13210 U.S.A. (315)476-3768 or (315)476-5541, ext 23
C. PROJECT
HEADQUARTERS:
1. Contact: The
Madison Project, 918 Irving Avenue, Syracuse, New York 13210, U.S.A. (315)476‑3768.
2. Special facilities or
activities available for visitor viewing:
By special arrangement it is possible to visit classrooms in
various schools, including culturally deprived situations, non-graded schools
using various forms of flexible programming and team teaching, etc. In
addition, it is possible to view project films (which also show actual
classroom lessons and to talk with project personnel about specific problems of
various sorts. Some project
classrooms center around "mathematics laboratories."
D. PRINCIPAL PROFESSIONAL
STAFF: Leon Henkin, Co-Director for Berkeley, California Implementation
Program; Donald Cohen, Resident Coordinator for New York City; Diane Resek,
Resident Coordinator for Berkeley, California; Beryl S. Cochran and Leah
Horwitz, Film Preparation; William McConnell, Co‑Director
for Implementation Programs; Edith Biggs, Robert Wirtz, Marion Walter, Katherine
Vaughn, Katie Reynolds Hannibal, and William Betts, Visiting Specialist
Teachers; Herbert Ginsburg, Co-Director for Piagetian Studies;
Joyce Statz, Co-Director for LOGO Computer Studies, Lucian Hall,
Resident Coordinator for Richmond, Virginia; George Grossman, New York City
Bureau of Curriculum.
E. PROJECT SUPPORT: 1.
Funding agencies: National Science Foundation; United States Office of
Education; Alfred P. Sloan Foundation; Marcel Hoizer Foundation; and a group of
industries and trade unions in the St. Louis area, plus contributions from
participating schools and colleges. 2. Associated agencies: Syracuse
University; University of California (Berkeley); Webster College; the Public
School System of: Berkeley, California; Richmond, Virginia; New York City;
Syracuse, New York; and the State Departments of Education in Delaware and in
California.
F. PROJECT HISTORY: 1.
Principal originators: Robert B. Davis, Beryl S. Cochran, Donald E. Kibbey,
Sister M. Francetta Barberis, S.L., and Jacqueline Grennan Wexler. 2. Date and
place of initiation: 1957; Syracuse, New York and Weston, Connecticut.
3. Evolution
and development of the project: The Project was originally started in order to
provide University faculty members who taught teachers with up-to-date
first-hand experience in directly teaching children, on the
principle that he who teaches experimental physics should himself be engaged in
experimental physics and if the principle holds in physics, why not also in
education. The original target-population were low achieving
children in grade seven who were significantly below grade level in
mathematics. These children were found to possess considerably more
mathematical ability than had been suspected. (The Project's work in
mathematics thus closely parallels the work of Hughes Mearnes and of Herbert
Kohl in the area of creative writing.) For the next 6 years the Project sought
to explore this unsuspected mathematical ability of children, working also with
high ses children at various grade levels; in the process of doing this, it
became necessary to develop a new mathematics curriculum, with selection of
topics, sequencing of topics, new notations, new definitions, etc., that were
more suitable for creative work by young children. (Thus, in this phase of its
activities, the Project generally resembled Seymour Papert and Wallace
Feurzeig's work on LOGO, and William Johntz's work on SEED.) The success of
this program led to the creation of large‑scale teacher
education programs. Joint ventures with the Elementary School Science (ESS)
Project of ES1/EDC, and with the British Nuffield Mathematics Project (and
other British educators) led to a greater use of manipulatable physical
materials, small group work, math labs, and student
projects. In its most recent stage, the Project is focussing on two matters:
first, the re‑orientation of methods of teaching, of testing, and of
curriculum planning that now seems necessary in the light of the discoveries
made by Jean Piaget and the Geneva group of cognitive psychologists; and,
second, with the new possibilities for school mathematics that have been
created by the Papert-Feurzeig development of the LOGO computer programming
language, and the various LOGO developments in hardware, in software, in
pedagogical techniques, and in curriculum design.
G. PROJECT OBJECTIVES: 1.
Overall project purpose: In broad terms, the purpose of the Project can be
stated as follows: The Project has seen educational settings where children
explore significant aspects of our present culture, and from such exploration
learn what this culture is, and how they themselves can function creatively
within it. (This general theme is well described in Casey and Liza Murrow,
Children Come First American Heritage Press, New York: 1971, and in Edith Biggs
and James MacLean, Freedom to Learn An Active Learning Approach to Mathematics
Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, Inc. Canada: 1969.) The Project is concerned
with helping schools and teachers set up such learning environments which
implies a need to study them more closely in order to see more clearly what
really is involved, and to prepare appropriate study materials that can be used
successfully in such environments. The Project has focussed on mathematics as
its main content area partly because Project personnel happen to be
mathematicians, and partly because mathematics plays a central role in schools
and in education.
2. Specific objectives:
(a) To study
the process of cognitive growth in children.
(b) To study
effective learning environments.
(C) To produce and
test learning materials for use by children and by teachers that will reflect
what can be found out from activities (a) and (b). The content area is mainly
mathematics, plus some science‑ but provision is made for
the inclusion of other content areas.
H. UNIQUE CHARACTERISTICS OF
THE PROJECT: The project is different primarily in two ways: first, its concern
for the great ability of most children which is untapped by most traditional
forms of schooling; and, second, its concern for the laws of human cognitive
growth.
I. SPECIFIC SUBJECTS, GRADE,
AGE AND ABILITY LEVELS: Subjects: Primarily mathematics, plus some science‑ but opportunities are provided to move into nearly
any area of study, by pursuing appropriate themes and appropriate methods.
Grade: Project practice is to attempt to avoid grade‑level segregation of children, and consequently
Project materials are un-graded. Most materials have been developed for use by
children between the ages of 8 years old, up to beginning college work;
however, some materials for use by younger children have been developed.
Ability levels: Project methods allow for adaptation to any ability level,
although the same curriculum is not used for children of widely different
abilities or interests.
J. MAIN METHODS OF
INSTRUCTION USED IN THE PROJECT: Independent study, laboratory investigations,
seminars, discussion sessions and small‑group work.
K. PRESENT COMMERCIAL
AFFILIATIONS: Books are presently available from Addison‑Wesley Publishing Company, Inc., San Hill Road, Menlo
Park, California 94025, U.S.A. Twelve films are scheduled for release in the
near future by Houghton Mifflin Company, 110 Tremont Street, Boston,
Massachusetts 02107. Subtraction and Division Using Beans and Beansticks;
Experience with Fractions: Suppose It Comes Out Even; Experience with
Fractions: Suppose It Doesn't Come Out Even; Fractions and the Meaning of
Division; Fractions on the Number Line, Using String The Number Line, Using the
Overhead Projector; Area, Using Geoboards. In addition, some
"shoebox" kits for math lab experiments are available from Math
Media, Inc., P. 0. Box 345, Danbury, Connecticut 06810. These kits are
entitled: Discs; Geoboards; Peg Game; Tower Puzzle; Centimeter Blocks, Weights
and Springs.
668
DESCRIPTION OF MATERIALS
ALREADY PRODUCED: 1. Discovery in Mathematics (Publishers, Addison-Wesley Publishing Co., Inc.) Student discussion guide, plus text for
teachers. This book provides a supplementary program in coordinate geometry,
axiomatic algebra, and applications to science, suitable especially for grades
4‑8. It is concerned particularly with creative learning
experiences of a non-routine nature. 2. Explorations in Mathematics Student
discussion guide, plus text for teachers. This book is concerned with
introductory ideas in algebra, statistics, mathematical logic, matrix algebra,
and some applications to physics. Special emphasis is placed upon historical
background, and the study of this book can be closely related to various units
in social studies (such as the life and times of Rene Descartes). It is
suitable for grades 6 through 9, inclusive. 3. A Modern Mathematics Program as
it Pertains to the Interrelationship of Mathematical Content, Teaching Methods,
and Classroom Atmosphere. (The Madison Project). 1963. Report submitted to the
Commissioner of Education, U.S. Office of Education, Fall, 1963. The provides a
general view of Madison Project activities. 4. A Modern Mathematics Program as
it Pertains to the Interrelationship of Mathematical Content, Teaching Methods,
and Classroom Atmosphere. (The Madison Project). 1965. Report submitted to the
Commissioner of Education, U.S. Office of Education, Fall, 1965. Note that this
is distinguishable from item 3 above only by the date. The 1965 report is the most
comprehensive description presently available of Madison Project materials and
activities. 5. The Madison Project A Brief Introduction to Materials and
Activities (1965). 6. Notes on the Film: First Lesson. (This pamphlet
accompanies the film of the same name.) 7. Robert B. Davis, Some Remarks on
"Learning By Discovery". 8. Robert B. Davis, The Next Few Years. 9.
Robert B. Davis, Experimental Course Report/Grade Nine.
10. Doris Machtinger,
Experimental Course Report/Kindergarten.
11. Donald Cohen, Inquiry in
Mathematics Via the Geoboard.
12. Supplementary Modern
Mathematics for Grades 1 through 9. In-Service Course #1
for Teachers. This is a complete "packaged" in‑service course, including films, written materials,
and laboratory equipment.
13. Supplementary Modern
Mathematics for Grades 2 through 9. In-Service Course #2
for Teachers. This is a sequel to item 12 above.
14. The Journal of Children's
Mathematical Behavior, (Vol. 1, No. 1 Winter 1971-72)
presently available. This informal journal discusses the development of
mathematical thought in children and how to study it.
15. A Concrete Approach to
Introductory Ideas in Mathematics (booklet accompanying film series listed in
item 16).
16. Film series (16mm, sound,
black and white) A Concrete Approach to Introductory Ideas in Mathematics.
Individual titles: Readiness for Place Value Numerals; A Sixth Grade Lesson on
Place Value Numerals; Subtraction Using Beans; Addition and Multiplication
Using Plastic Washers; Addition and Division Using Beans and Beansticks;
Subtraction and Division
Using Beans and Beansticks;
Experience with Fractions: Suppose It Comes Out Even; Experience with
Fractions: Suppose It Doesn't Come Out Even; Fractions and the Meaning of
Division; Fractions on the Number Line, Using String; The Number Line, Using
the Overhead Projector; Area, Using Geoboards.
17. Audio tape recording #D‑1: + =
2 x . This is a
recording of an actual classroom lesson with fifth grade children, proving
algebraic theorems from a set of axioms selected by themselves.
18. Film (16mm., sound, black
and white) A Lesson with Second Graders. This film shows an actual classroom
lesson involving signed numbers, the number line, and Cartesian co‑ordinates.
Viewing this film is one of
the best introductions to project activities.
19. Film (16mm., sound, black
and white) Complex Numbers via Matrices. This film shows an actual classroom
lesson. Seventh grade students use the isomorphism between rational numbers an
a subset of the set 2 by 2 matrices to facilitate an
extension into complex numbers.
20. Film (16mm., sound, black
and white) Matrices. An actual classroom lesson. Fifth and sixth graders
explore the algebra of 2‑by‑2 matrices.
21. Film (16 mm.,
sound, black and white) Solving Equations
With Matrices. An actual classroom
lesson, similar to item 1 above, but less sophisticated. Sixth grade students.
22. Film (16mm., sound, black
and white) Average and Variance An actual classroom lesson, with 6th grade
children.
23. Film (16mm., sound, black
and white) Graphing an Ellipse. An actual classroom lesson, with 7th grade
students.
24. Film (16mm., sound, black
and white) Circles and Parabola An actual classroom lesson, with 6th grade
children.
25. Film (16mm., sound, black
and white) First Lesson. An actual classroom lesson, with a mixed class of
children from grades 3 to 7.
26. Film (16mm., sound, black
and white) Second Lesson. This lesson occurred on the day following that shown
in item 25 above, with the same students.
27. Film (16mm., sound, black
and white) Weights and Springs. A "laboratory" lesson, with 6th grade
children.
28. Film (16mm., sound, black
and white) Graphing a Parabola. This is a portion of the film listed in item
20.
29. Film (16mm., sound, black
and white) Guessing Functions. A seventh grade class of culturally deprived
urban children.
30. "shoebox"
packages for physical experiments related to the mathematics program, or for
physical and tactile experiences related to the learning of mathematics.
Titles: Discs, Geoboards, Peg Game, Tower Puzzle, Centimeter Blocks, Weights
and Springs.
31. (The Project also makes
use of physical materials prepared by Z. P. Dienes, by ESS, by the Nuffield
Project, and by others as well as desk calculators of various sorts.
M. MATERIALS AVAILABLE FREE:
This varies according to the availability of reprints of various articles.
Contact the Madison Project, 918 Irving Avenue, Syracuse, New York 13210.
N. MATERIALS PURCHASABLE:
Items 1 and 2 from Section L. Item 1: Student text $3.21; Teacher text $8.40.
Item 2: Student text $3.40; Teacher text $9.24. (Order from Regional Office,
Addison‑Wesley Publishing Company, Inc.) Item 11 available
from Walker Educational Book Corporation, 720 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York
10019. Item 14, The Journal of Children's Mathematical Behavior available from
The Madison Project, 918 Irving Avenue, Syracuse, New York 13210. Price
(subject to change): $1.00 Items 15 and 16: Available soon from Houghton
Mifflin Co., 110 Tremont Street, Boston, Massachusetts 02160. Item 29:
"shoebox" kits available from Math Media, Inc., P. 0. Box 345,
Danbury, Connecticut 06810. Price for complete set of 6: $19.00. Four or more
sets: $17.25 each.
0. ADDITIONAL MATERIALS BEING
DEVELOPED: Please refer to present and future issues of The Journal of
Children's Mathematical Behavior.
P. LANGUAGE OF MATERIALS: 1.
As originally written: English. 2. Have been or will be translated:
Explorations in Mathematics; Parts Two and Five have been translated into
Japanese. Japanese translation available from: Addison‑Wesley Publishing Company, Inc., International
Division, Reading Massachusetts.
Q. COUNTRIES IN WHICH
MATERIALS ARE USED: U.S.A., Canada, Great Britain, Japan, Korea, India,
Vietnam, Ghana, Nigeria, Uganda, Israel, Australia, New Zealand.
R. PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION.
The project materials are widely used. Exact figures are unknown. Exemplary
classrooms may be located by contacting The Madison Project coordinators listed
in D. See, especially, classrooms in Berkeley, California and in New York City.
S. TEACHER PREPARATION: 1.
Consultant service available for teachers using the materials: In New York
City; in Berkeley, California; in St. Louis, Missouri; in Washington, D. C.,
and elsewhere. Contact the Project at its Syracuse address for information.
Consultants
are prepared to assist
teachers, administrators, or interested parents in a variety of ways, including
program planning and practical classroom implementation. 2. Activities
conducted for pre‑service and in‑service teacher
training: Extensive in‑service programs are available in New York City, in
Delaware, and in California. Details available from the Project. 3. Available
pre‑service and/or in‑service
teaching materials for science educators to use in preparing teachers: In‑Service Course I (dealing with ways of combining
arithmetic, algebra, and analytic geometry to provide a broad elementary school
program), consists of printed materials and ten film excerpts available at a
cost of $30.00 for rental of the films and $100.00 for 30 copies of the printed
materials (or, single copies $3.50). A more diverse in‑service or pre‑service teacher
education package which includes consideration of mathematics in open
classrooms is now undergoing trials. Preliminary versions are available at a
cost of $3.00.
T. PROJECT EVALUATION: 1. Has
the effectiveness of the materials been evaluated: Yes, internally and by the
California State Department of Education, Far West Laboratory for Research and
Development. 2. Pertinent published research studies: "Research Report of
the Specialized Teacher Project 1968‑69."
California State Department of Education, Sacramento, California, February
1970; Kathleen Devaney, "An ALERT Report on The Madison Project,"
1972. Available from the Educational Information Products Division, Far West Laboratory
for Educational Research and Development, 1 Garden Circle, Hotel Claremont,
Berkeley, Calif. 94705.; Alan Barson, Beryl Cochran and Robert Davis,
"Child‑Created Mathematics," The Arithmetic Teacher,
March 1970.; J. Robert Cleary, "A Study of Test Performance in Two Madison
Project Schools and One Control School," Webster College, St. Louis,
Missouri. 3. Brief abstract of in‑house or
unpublished research: By far the best evidence concerning the mathematical
behavior of children in Project classes is provided by actual videotape and
film records showing what children do: conjecturing theorems proving them,
analyzing new problem situations, etc. These films and videotapes show not
merely that the children do do all of this‑ they show
precisely how the children do it. These films are available for loan or rental.
For details write to the Project. 4. Evaluative data available to interested
individuals: Please see the preceding remark (question T‑3).
U. PROJECT PUBLICITY: 1.
Davis, Robert B. "Report of the Syracuse University Webster College
Madison Project." American Mathematical Monthly Vol. 71, No. 3 (March,
1964) pp. 306‑308.
2. _. "The Madison
Project's Approach to a Theory of Instruction," Journal of Research in
Science Teaching Vol. 2 (1964), pp. 146‑162. 3. ,
"The Next Few Years," The Arithmetic Teacher Vol. 13, No. 5 (May,
1966), pp. 355‑362. 4. . The Changing Curriculum: Mathematics.
Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development, NEA, 1967. 5. Yeomans,
Edward. Education for Imitative and Responsibility Comments on a visit to the
Schools of Leicestershire County. National Association of Independent Schools,
Boston, Mass. 2nd edition, February 1968. 6. Pine, Patricia. "New Math
Road Show," American Education Vol. 4, No. 7, July‑August 1968. 7. M. Vere De Vault and Thomas Kriewall,
Perspectives in Elementary School Mathematics, Charles Merrill Company, 1969.
8. "Nuffield Mathematics Project: Teacher's Guides," Mathematics
Teaching No. 53, Winter, 1970, pp. 53‑56. 9.
Ginsburg, Herbert, The Myth of the Deprived Child, Prentice Hall, Inc.,
Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey, 1972.
10. Davis, Robert B.,
"Observing Children's Mathematical Behavior as a Foundation for Curriculum
Planning," The Journal of Children's Mathematical Behavior Vol.
1, No. 1 (Winter1971‑72).
V. BRIEF SUMMARY OF PROJECT
ACTIVITIES SINCE 1970 REPORT: The Project has a new major focus: the careful
observation of the mathematical behavior of children. This may provide a
sounder foundation for curriculum design, and a more effective point of
intervention for changing school mathematics, than any that have been used
previously. The "careful observation of children" involves depth
studies in the sense of Piaget, and NOT a main focus on superficial verbal
behavior.
W. PLANS FOR THE FUTURE: 1.
The process of preparing films and videotapes for release by Houghton Mifflin,
or otherwise, will continue with a growing list of films becoming available. 2.
The program of observing and describing the mathematical behavior of children
will become a main emphasis in Project activity. (Cf., Robert B. Davis,
"The Problems of Relating Mathematics to the Possibilities and Needs of
Schools and Children," in H. Freudenthal, ed., Educational Studies in
Mathematics, D. Reidel Publishing Company (Holland), June 1971. 3. The
establishment of consultants and in‑service study
opportunities in various geographical areas will be expanded especially in
California, New York City, Delaware, Baltimore, and the area around Washington,
D.C.). 4. Methodological and even philosophical matters, in specific cases
which the Project judges to be of immediate practical relevance, will be
pursued. (Cf. Robert B. Davis, Mathematics Teaching‑ With Special Reference to Epistemological Problems.
Monograph No. 1 (Fall, 1967), of the Journal of Research and Development in
Education, College of Education, University of Georgia, Athens, Georgia 30601.
5. More attention will be given to mathematics in relation to open education.
(Casey and Liza Murrow, Children Come First, American Heritage Press, New York,
1971). 6. An elementary school mathematics program, for presentation to
children via the PLATO computer system, will be developed jointly with UICSM.
7. Children will be studied as they learn the BBN/MIT LOGO computer programming
language. 8. The Project will participate in an international comparison of how
curriculum development and innovation efforts are undertaken in various nations
of Europe and Asia.